Newsroom

    When a Full and Final Settlement Might Not be as Full and Final as Intended

    Author //

    • Adam Khan Senior Associate
      Phone: 61 7 3001 9260
      Email: a.khan@clarkekann.com.au

    The High Court's recent Judgment in Lavin v Toppi contains useful reminders and guidance on the liability of co-sureties.

    Litigation & Insolvency Associate, Adam Khan, looks at the broader implications of the case.

    THE FACTS

    Mrs Lavin and Ms Toppi guaranteed a loan advanced by a bank to a company. Mrs Lavin and Ms Toppi were directors of the company. After the company went into receivership, the bank sued the guarantors. Mrs Lavin sought a declaration from the Court that the guarantee was unenforceable, but then settled the matter by payment of $1.35M. The settlement deed contained a covenant by the bank not to sue Mrs Lavin for the balance of the guaranteed debt.

    Ms Toppi then sold her home and the proceeds of sale were used to pay the balance of the guaranteed debt to the bank, which was about $2.9M. The bank then discharged the guarantors from their obligations under the guarantee.

    THE PROCEEDINGS

    Ms Toppi successfully brought proceedings to recover a contribution from Mrs Lavin for the difference between the respective amounts paid by Mrs Lavin and Ms Toppi in discharging the guarantee. That decision was upheld on appeal. Mrs Lavin appealed to the High Court.

    THE APPEAL TO THE HIGH COURT

    On appeal, Mrs Lavin argued:
    • Her liability was different to Ms Toppi's because Ms Toppi's liability was enforceable by the bank whereas, because of the covenant not to sue, Mrs Lavin's was not;
    • Ms Toppi had not benefited from Mrs Lavin's discharge and that was fatal since the purpose of contribution is to prevent the unjust enrichment by one co-surety at the expense of another; and
    • at the time when Ms Toppi sought a contribution, there was no coordinate liability because Mrs Lavin could no longer be sued by the bank.

    THE DECISION

    The High Court dismissed the appeal and each of Mrs Lavin's arguments.

    The following principles emerge from the Judgment:
    • The rationale of the right to contribution is one of natural justice that ensures that persons who are under coordinate liabilities must share the burden pro rata, with respect to the liability of other guarantors is fully understood.
    • Once the company had defaulted on repayment (or once the bank had made a demand), the guarantors had a common obligation to pay the whole guaranteed debt. A covenant not to sue does not operate as a discharge of the guaranteed liability.
    • The covenant not to sue meant the liability of Mrs Lavin was not enforceable by legal proceedings, but it was enforceable by other means such as reliance on rights of recoupment under other securities (if any) between the bank and Mrs Lavin.
    • Without a right of contribution, the co-surety who pays less than his or her fair share in discharging the shared liability is unjustly enriched.
    • On equitable grounds, the Court will step in to correct an imbalance if the creditor, who can demand payment from all guarantors, fixes one party with liability for all of the debt.

    WIDER RELEVANCE AND IMPLICATIONS

    There are a number of points to take from this decision:

    • Co-guarantors should be wary before entering agreements with creditors unless the position with respect to the liability of other guarantors is fully understood.
    • If a full and final agreement between a co- guarantor and a creditor contains, or is properly understood to be, a covenant not to sue, then it is unlikely to affect the co-guarantor's liability to other guarantors.
    • A co-liability to a creditor is not discharged until it is fully paid or the creditor provides a full discharge and release.
    • Creditors should be wary of the effect of entering an agreement with a single co- guarantor and providing full discharges for part payment of a debt when all that is really intended is a covenant not to sue.

    It is advisable, prior to entering into an agreement with respect to a shared liability, that legal advice is sought and taken on the possible implications of the agreement.

    ClarkeKann is a commercial law firm with offices in Brisbane and Sydney. Our expertise covers commercial & corporate transactions, employment & IR, financial services, litigation, risk management and insolvency, property transactions and resources projects, across a range of industries. For a full list of our legal services, please visit our website at www.clarkekann.com.au. To update your contact details or unsubscribe to any of our publications, email us at ck@clarkekann.com.au

    This bulletin is produced as general information in summary for clients and subscribers and should not be relied upon as a substitute for detailed legal advice or as a basis for formulating business or other decisions. ClarkeKann asserts copyright over the contents of this document. This bulletin is produced by ClarkeKann. It is intended to provide general information in summary form on legal topics, current at the time of publication. The contents do not constitute legal advice and should not be relied upon as such. Formal legal advice should be sought in particular matters. Liability limited by a scheme approved under professional standards legislation. Privacy Policy
    < Back to Articles

People

Property & Projects Partners Paul O'Dea and Steven Cardell were recently listed in Doyle's Guide to the Australian Legal Profession as leading Property Law Lawyers (Queensland) for 2019. To make this list requires feedback from various sources but most importantly our clients. We thank our clients for that valuable input and look forward to assisting in your continued commercial growth. VIEW MORE

Expertise

ClarkeKann has received the Australia-Taiwan Business Excellence Award for our efforts promoting and advising on most of the major investments from Taiwan into Australia over the last 20 years. Click below for more details about Foreign InvestmentVIEW MORE

Subscribe

Click below to subscribe to our publications and to receive the latest news VIEW MORE